My short list is down to Pajero Sport, Subaru Outback or FJ Cruiser. I need room for a large dog, luggage and some off-road ability. Occasional towing the garden trailer and carrying passengers. Mostly used for short trips around town which is why I'm not fussed about diesel. We currently have a 7-seater Toyota Kluger.
I like the exterior look of the FJ although think it's old tech. I hate the look of the rear of the Pajero, otherwise it seems to tick many boxes. My concerns with the Subaru are around the longevity and reliability of the CVT transmission.
Up front I think you really need to quantify what degree of all-terrain capability you require. The harder you want to go off road, the more you'd lean to the Pajero Sport or the FJ - but you have to accept a certain lack of civility on road if you go that way.
When you say “some off-road ability” I’m assuming you mean dirt roads and very easy tracks, as opposed to the ascent of Mt Blue Rag in the Vic Alps. Big difference in the vehicles needed for either application.
I would say the Outback has little to no off-road ability whatsoever, but is quite at home on decent dirt roads and some very easy tracks. Subaru Outback review >> Pajero Sport and FJ Cruiser both have proper off-road capability: as in, they can do things that would terrify average owners.
I agree with you that the Pajero Sport rear is the metaphoric hatful of proverbials (what were they thinking?) but the FJ is an old Prado with a ridiculous Tonka Toy-style body, and only available with an OPEC profit pumping up, sailor-on-shore-leave thirst, thanks to its 4.0-litre inline petrol six … so it's not as if one’s a stunner and the other's a bush pig. Mitsubishi Pajero Sport review >>
I share your reservations about the CVT in the Outback, but I am told the 3.6 gets a higher capacity CVT than the 2.5. Perhaps that helps (and perhaps it's part of the $7k price hike from 2.5i Premium to 3.6R).
EyeSight is Subaru's brilliant safety system, which delivers a suite of camera-based safety features like auto emergency braking, adaptive cruise, lane-departure and blind spot warnings, etc. It's very advanced, and might save your life (or someone else's). You don'y get anything like that in the Pajero Sport or FJ Cruiser.
If you want to do some moderate to serious off-roading: The Pajero Sport. Make friends with the elongated lights. You can’t see them as you drive, in any case.
Sorento GT-Line is the $64,000 question - literally. It's both 'mainstream' and 'luxury'. Should you drop the big bucks on the fully-loaded Sorento?
Will cargo down the back become lethal projectiles and guillotine you in a crash? Why don’t all wagons and hatches come standard with cargo barriers?
Will towing a trailer with a dual clutch transmission compromise the vehicle's reliability, and how do you drive a DCT to prolong clutch life>
Many people waste large sums of cash buying the wrong vehicle. Immunise yourself against marketing BS now - and choose the right SUV.
A lot of people think their new SUV is tantamount to indestructible. Au contraire. Here's how easy it is to cost yourself thousands
How do you tell which SUV will be more economical in the real world - and if you've got the cash for a new one, do you really care?
You're considering a diesel, but you've heard horror stories about DPFs and sky-high replacement cost. Here's what you need to know.
Seven-seat SUVs come in two basic 'flavours': hard and soft. Which one is right for you depends entirely on what you plan to do with it.
What's the most cost-effective and tax-effective way to buy a seven-seat SUV for my business, and how do you set that up efficiently?
Are diesels compatible with short trips, or is this a path to diesel ownership hell? What type of driving is required to keep a diesel healthy?
Two relatively sexy SUVs and one - let's face it - fairly un-sexy people mover: but which is actually best for transporting a large family?
How important is buying a car at the end of a particular month. A great deal is made of end-of-month timing, but does the month itself really matter?